Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Using Profitability to Measure Direct Marketing Campaigns


As you know, we are huge proponents of measuring the effectiveness of each and every direct marketing campaign -- and looking specifically at the profitability of all DM efforts. If you don't do this, how can you improve your programs over time to ensure that your profits continue to grow? Further, how do you prove to your leadership team (or yourself) that the costs spent on marketing are well worth the effort?

Our friends at Acxiom have just written about this very topic in their latest newsletter, and they came up with a quick and easy template that you can use for your own direct marketing efforts. We like this simple chart because there are some key takeaways to hone in on no matter what the size of your marketing organization.

Take a look at this chart:

If you were just looking at the response rate to measure the effectiveness of these three tests, you'd think (and probably promote internally) that the campaign with the offer of the free gift was the most successful. I mean, come on, a 2.5% response rate? We'll take that all day long, right?

However, when you look at a slightly bigger picture -- the conversion rate, resulting sales less all other costs -- a whole new story unfolds. And, based upon profitability, you would make an entirely different decision about which campaign was the most effective -- and by far! And, by the way, the test with the free gift offer and the highest response rate is the least profitable of the three campaigns! This picture tells a different story, no?

Granted, you may have a few more categories than this to measure, but the point is that the process can be very straight forward. It doesn't take a team of analysts and as Acxiom's newsletter points out, you can do this over lunch on a napkin!

When you measure the ROI of each campaign, you are putting yourself on a path of continuous improvement. You learn from your mistakes and you take advantage of your brilliance. From our viewpoint, there is no reason not to do this.

So, as you're considering your next DM campaign, take a few extra moments to understand the profitability. When the end of the year rolls around and you begin to look at your P&L, you'll really be glad you did this. And as budgets are scrutinized, marketing will look like a profit-center, not a cost-center. I think we can all agree that this is the desired outcome!

Monday, April 28, 2008

Case Study: Importance of B2B Lead Scoring


You know that we're huge advocates of using statistical techniques to improve marketing performance. So, when I listened to Richard Sharp, VP of Marketing for Marqui speak on the topic of lead scoring at the Innotech e-marketing conference earlier this month, I knew it would be a great session. Richard spoke about how important it is for marketing to qualify leads through an objective scoring system, prior to handing the right leads over to sales.

We couldn't agree more and we decided to highlight a Marqui client success in this Monday's Case Study. This success story comes directly from their sales literature.

Background and Client
Strangeloop Networks develops a family of network appliances designed to help businesses optimize the performance of their website or web-based application. Their business clients can then deliver new features and applications faster and at a lower cost without changes to software code or hardware infrastructure.

Challenges
Strangeloop Networks was a newly launched company that needed to hit the ground running. With limited marketing staff and budget, they still had to deliver enough sales-ready leads for their team. They had to transform their website from "brochure-ware" into an active lead generation component. They also had to create lead generation campaigns that could easily plug into their existing Salesforce CRM and Google Analytics web analytics package. They wanted a more effective means of evaluating their marketing programs instead of relying on conflicting anecdotal information from their sales team.

Solution
Strangeloop selected the Marqui Marketing Automation Suite, as it included key features and guaranteed a fast implementation. The Marqui Marketing Automation Suite provided both web content management and marketing campaign tools, offering a single-vendor solution. Total implementation time including training was only a few weeks before they were able to start running their first lead generation campaign.

Results
  • Executed campaigns 3x faster
  • Reduced budget for external contractors by $14,400 annually
  • Increased conversion rate by 10% each onth
  • Established automated workflow for managing and approving content
  • Ability to track profitability of multi-channel campaigns
All in all, sounds pretty impressive! It's great to see small businesses succeed by being clever, and by choosing the right technology.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Links of the Week!

Another week has come to an end -- so time for the weekend!

To get your weekend started, here are our favorite links this week:

Ron Shevlin's Direct Marketing Whims: Ron has a great blog -- and he is really smart and better than that, he's extremely funny. So, we love reading his posts. Our favorite post this week concerns his favorite industry -- banking -- and how two particular marketing channels (branches and online) interact to create satisfied customers. And, further, he makes the point that particular customers need to be able to interact through different channels -- depending upon their specific preferences. Bottom line: all channels are cost centers but are very important to the customer experience. Our take is that no matter what the industry, if you're utilizing all channels to better serve the customer, and taking the time to understand customer preferences, the costs incurred will be money well spent because you'll keep your customers satisfied -- and loyal to your brand.

With our celebration of Earth Day this week, here is a wonderful post from Dan Smolen's Sturdy Roots blog. Dan is a marketing recruiter, and he specializes in in hooking up environmentally conscious companies with like-minded direct marketing professionals. His post this week was a great one about the need for businesses to embrace the concept of virtual office employees -- especially those outside of sales. Both Suzanne and I have been virtual office employees for most of our professional career -- whether in corporate America or self-employed. It's definitely a good thing -- it saves time, wear-and-tear and the environment. Check out this post -- we think you'll like it. Dan gives some great ideas about how to open your mind to allowing more employees to be virtual, and how to do it most effectively.

Mobilestorm's Digital Marketing blog had a very interesting post this week on how internet video is the 21st Century Gold Rush. The post quotes the NY Times as saying: "A Florida-based producer, whose clips are on varied topics like 'how to turn a flashlight into a laser' and “how to simulate a gunshot wound,” earned more than $102,000 in a year from MetaCafe, which pays content owners according to how many views their videos garner." This is wacky -- but there is a whole revenue-generating world out there making bazillionaires with internet videos. Crazy!

Finally -- and selfishly -- take a listen to my favorite acoustic finger-style guitarist, Steve Berger. Steve also happens to be my husband who has just created a site featuring many of his original songs over the past 25 years or so. I'm pretty proud of him as you can probably tell! If any of you would like to become his fans after listening to his music, please feel free to do so (you just sign up with SoundClick as a listener, then select the "Fan+" button from Steve's page)! Take a listen to the song "Time to Live My Life," which is the story of how Steve made the difficult decision to leave his life in Corporate America to pursue his musical passions. I think that this song will resonate with many!

Have a great weekend!

Grow Your Customer Relationships


You know you're getting old when news doesn't seem like news. You've heard it before. Same old story. Can you relate?

It's certainly how I felt reading this story from DM News: Study says CMOs are failing to use CRM well.
"Marketers worldwide are under-utilizing data and analyt­ics, particularly when it comes to customer retention, according to a recent study released by the Chief Marketing Officer Council.

Only half of marketers have a strategy in place for growing key account relationships, and 45% believe CRM systems are not effective enough. Further, only 15% of companies rated them­selves extremely good or effective at integrating disparate customer data sources, and 6% of marketers reported having “excellent knowl­edge” of customer data such as demographics, psychographics or transactional history."
The article goes on to talk about how so many companies continue to be focused on new customer acquisition and fall short in developing strategies designed to retain the customer.

In today's environment of short-term gratification (we must meet sales goals THIS MONTH; we have to report favorable earnings THIS QUARTER), I tend to understand why a long-term, customer-centric strategy might fall by the wayside. Couple the need for immediate results with an ever-shrinking marketing staff and budget, and I start to wonder how any company can think strategically and look at long-term benefits.

But, here's the kicker--this way of thinking with the customer in mind is a necessity. Customers today are aware of the data and technology that is available to corporations. They see it used to their advantage in their everyday dealings (the classic example is shopping with Amazon). They expect you to know all about them. They want you to anticipate their needs. They need you to serve them the right price plan or the right mix of products. If you won't do it, you're in danger of losing that customer.

It may be time to look at your customer touch-points and make sure that you're doing all you can to keep those customers happy.

Following is a short-list of ideas that might jump-start the evaluation process:
  • Have you empowered your call center or customer service folks to really assist customers calling in with issues? Are they able to make real fixes and solve problems?
  • Do you have a handle on your customer relationships? Have you done the analysis and database work to understand exactly what products and services each customer is buying from you (or has purchased in the past)?
  • Do you have a strategy in-place to make sure that you are maximizing the profit potential from each and every customer? Do you make the right up-sell and cross-sell offers, when the customer is most likely to be shopping?
  • Conversely, do you have a strategy in place to ensure that you are not over-serving your customer? For example, are they on a price plan that is too big for their needs, hence they're paying too much? Trust me, eventually, your customer will realize that they've been paying too much for your service, and they'll leave you. To retain this customer and maximize their lifetime value, perhaps you should be pro-active and "right-size" their plan, before they do...
Luckily, we direct marketers, with our background and experience in data mining and using analytics to understand--and predict--customer behavior, are well-positioned to make a positive impact on customer marketing. Nancy and I have re-focused our direct marketing consulting practice to be centered on analytics and data. It's that important, we believe.

Perhaps it's time to become the customer advocate within your organization!

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

More on Telecommunications -- AT&T's Success Story


As you know, Suzanne posted yesterday about how some forward-thinking telecommunications companies are marketing themselves more aggressively to keep their customers for the long-term. While it doesn't sound like rocket science, it wasn't so long ago that this just never happened. In the past, it was simply a mind-set of try to bring on as many customers as you lose, and you'll stay even. And, as direct marketers . . . as business-people . . . we know that this is an insane approach!

At the end of her post, Suzanne posed a couple of questions about why the traditional telecommunications giants weren't mentioned in this research and asked for reader comments/opinions.

Well, today, the Washington Post reports that AT&T has just announced a 21.5% gain in the first quarter of 2008. And, this in a time of economic slowdown! The article goes on to report that "The country's largest telecommunications company earned $3.46 billion in the quarter, compared with $2.85 billion in the first quarter of 2007. Revenue rose 6 percent, to $30.74 billion." Um . . . that's "B" for Billion.

Regarding the economic slowdown, CFO Richard G. Lindner said that "apart from some 'softness' in local phone lines, there was little sign of the weakness in the U.S. economy affecting the company.

Hmmm . . . so, the biggest of the traditional telecommunications firms continues to grow in a softening economy to the tune of over 21%. The article doesn't mention AT&T's marketing efforts specifically but it does mention that the growth is definitely spurred on by AT&T Mobility.

Now, Dave from the Motley Fool has his opinion as to why AT&T is so successful. Can you say iPhone? Here are Dave's thoughts, "I see two major trends pushing the wireless-data wave along: broadband-equipped laptops and the Apple iPhone. With corporate types and "prosumers" willing to pay a premium for mobile broadband connectivity, AT&T is capturing high-margin revenue as it rolls out this service across the U.S. And the game-changing iPhone is encouraging more people to browse the Web on a mobile device and buy audio and video media -- again, at a high margin."

It'll be interesting to see if AT&T's strategy of partnering with cool technology players pays off -- as it obviously thus far with Apple. It'll also be interesting to see if due to their intelligent partnering approach if they'll need to do what the other players are doing in terms of their marketing efforts.

From what we can tell, AT&T definitely hit the number 5 key trend in marketing from yesterday's post: "Telecoms use new emerging media channels to reach early adopters." AT&T's partnership with Apple definitely is reaching the early adopters or prosumers (as our friend Dave calls them). And those folks that I've seen who have purchased the iPhone definitely use all of it's functionality -- which equates to more revenue for AT&T.

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Direct Marketing for the Telecommunications Industry


This is a topic rather dear to our hearts. Nancy and I both have quite a bit of experience working with telecommunications firms and helping them develop and implement winning marketing programs.

So, when I come across an article that talks about direct marketing for this industry, I get excited (yes, I know I'm a geek). From DM News, Fierce competition among telecom marketers.

The article talks about how deregulation and new technology have made telecom a super competitive marketplace. It talks about the importance of timing and reaching that prospect just when their service plan is about to expire (a tough challenge that we know a thing or two about, by the way!).

The article cites 5 key trends in marketing for telecommunications firms:
  1. "Telecoms leverage more online channels to maximize spend." They're relying on consumers doing their own research on the Internet and building an online presence to acquire new customers.
  2. "With short contracts, timing of messages is essential."
  3. "Many programs are tied to contextual ads and paid search to drive traffic."
  4. "Companies are differentiating themselves with aggressive calls to action." In a nutshell, they're serving up great offers, many with a cost/savings focus. The article mentioned that the word "free" is used a lot in telecom advertising.
  5. "Telecoms use new emerging media channels to reach early adopters." They're using blogs and social networks as a low-cost way to get their message out to the technology community.
The article gives real examples of marketing programs for telecommunications companies. Interesting stuff.

But, here's what I found probably the most interesting about the entire article. Not one example, not one single mention was given to the traditional telecom providers. By traditional, I'm talking about those companies that used to be referred to as the Regional Bell Operating Companies (RBOCs). You know, Verizon, BellSouth, SBC, Qwest, etc. Nor, is giant AT&T mentioned. Not even once.

Those telecom marketers that ARE mentioned include: Vonage, Jajah (a provider of VOIP services), Avaya, Time Warner Telecom and Helio. Hmmm.

So, here are my questions: Do you think that the firms that I'm calling "traditional" simply don't have to put forth innovative marketing because they've locked in market-share?

Or, do you think that the landscape is changing so much that within the next few years, the majority of us will be buying our telecom from different players?

Or, ARE the traditional giants actually putting forth innovative marketing, programs and products and they're just not mentioned in this article?

I'd love to hear opinions, please!

Monday, April 21, 2008

Case Study Monday: eROI and Wacom


Welcome to another edition of Case Study Monday. This Case Study comes to us from a conference up in Portland, Oregon, that Suzanne attended last week. The conference was an e-marketing summit called Innotech. eROI was one of the many companies who presented at the conference. They are a leading e-mail and interactive agency. They presented this case study at the conference, and we found it so compelling we thought we'd share it with you. We hope you enjoy this great example of using creativity to create a community -- and how eROI helped their client, Wacom, effectively utilize social marketing.

Wacom -- Power of the Pens, Building a Community Wacom products have become such an essential tool to digital artists. The company bridges the gap between fine arts and today’s digital workflow. So much so, in fact, that even those who have never used a Wacom product know the brand by name.

For this campaign, we wanted to share that connection of experienced and new artists. We wanted to turn brand awareness into full-fledged adoption. We did this by bringing in a group of experienced artists and asking them to document their creative process, and ultimately, share some final work.

We really wanted the participants to express themselves freely, so we tried to keep
the creative brief open — restricting artists never leads to great work. The only direction we gave was in choosing artists who represented 12 different areas of expertise that we knew would produce visually interesting work: graffiti, animation, flash, poster art, illustration, photography, air brush, graphic design, apparel, motionography, toy design and Portland’s cut & paste winner (a Wacom-focused art event).

To help focus the campaign, give it consumer relevancy and create a sense of time, we formatted the campaign around a wallpaper calendar. Each artist was tasked to create a month for the calendar, using their specific talent. As predicted through our strategic selection, the body of work produced was extremely diverse, and all produced using Wacom technology.

On top of the campaign highlighting the artistic potential Wacom offers, and pushing the connection to the artist community, we wanted to help increase direct sales through Wacom’s online store. To do this, we not only shared the 12 pieces of fresh art, and the thought process behind it, but also the making of the art and the tools used. This allowed us to work the product in for each artist without seeming pushy, but rather informative and helpful.

We called it the designer toolbox, and it worked out really nicely, highlighting a wide array of products from multiple pens and pen tips, to on-screen tablets and special edition tablets. The varied products in each artist’s designer toolbox, and the soft sell they created, allowed us to send an email for 12 straight days (a non-standard practice) without losing the interest of recipients.

Instead of consumers receiving product heavy calls to action, which can feel overwhelming during the holiday email push, they were receiving interesting content with tantalizing artwork. This artwork drove to the site where the wallpaper calendar resided. Again, the marketing was very subtle with the wallpaper highlighting the art, and only allowing a small Wacom logo to reside next to the calendar in the upper right. The beauty here, is that the logo gets placed on someone’s desktop for a year-long exposure. People actually choose to look at it and become evangelists.

The site produced a real community, spurred on by a glimpse at the professional artists, their process, their work environments and, perhaps most of all, by a user-generated independent digital art gallery. Building the artist profiles in a blog allowed for the community to offer numerous comments. To wrap up the campaign, the user-generated artwork with the most votes was selected to win Wacom’s new cintiq12wX.

We took our thinking beyond this holiday campaign, with the idea of a continued community built from the ground up for Wacom’s impassioned artistic followers. Utilizing the power of Wacom’s house list, we were able to promote the campaign site to a list of over 200,000 Wacom news subscribers. This list included all opt-ins who wished to receive information from Wacom (newsletters, product updates, etc.).

To help market the campaign, we used a small PR push from Wacom’s internal team and a banner ad placed on the Wacom America home page. Marketing was limited because the concept behind the site was to have the creative community do the promotion by uploading their art and communicating to their audiences that they want to win a new Wacom product.

The hope (and these days it's a good bet), was that members of this community would have blogs or some other communication methods to help draw people to the site. That means free advertising from artists embracing the site and encouraging folks to vote for their work on their blogs and various message boards. The goal was to have the campaign be entirely organic with no internal message board or blog seeding, really making it all about the artists and the work.

Results
At the end of the 14 day campaign, over 61,000 unique visitors from all over the world had come to the site, over 2,000 user generated images were uploaded, over 150 comments were left for the 12 Wacom artists. Wacom added over 2,000 new subscribers to their house list A success? We think so.

That’s the power of the pens!